Menu for Muddy's Bake Shop LLC

Current Weeks
|
Vegan Items
|
Shop

Current Weeks

Pies by the Slice and Puddings‍

Shady Wake Pie

Chocolate Dream Pie

Nancy's Boy Pie

Rum Raisin Pie

Johnny Appleseed Pie

Kick in the Pants Pie

7″ & 4″ Whole Pies Available While They Last in Limited Flavors!

Banana Puddin’

Oreo Puddin’

Dirt ‘N’ Worms

Cookies and Bars

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Jan’s famous toffee bars

Oatmeal Coconut

Double Chocolate Sea Salt Cookies

Coconut Macaroons

Salty Sweet Cookies

Espresso Brownies

Iced Heart Cookies

Cupcakes (Cake/Icing)‍

Prozac (Chocolate/Chocolate)

Capote (Chocolate/Vanilla)

Plain Jane (Vanilla/Vanilla)

Frankly Scarlett (Red Velvet/Cream Cheese)

Classic (Vanilla/Chocolate)

Pucker Up (Lemon/Lemon)

Grasshopper (Chocolate/Peppermint)

Cookies N Cream (Chocolate/Oreo)

New Yorker (Chocolate/Cream Cheese)

Monkey Around (Banana/Banana)

Cappuccino (Vanilla/Cappuccino)

Citrus Explosion (Lemon/Orange)

Vegan

Mocha Madness Cupcake (Chocolate/Mocha)

Almond Brothers Cupcakes (Almond/Almond)

Vegan Items

Cakes and Cupcakes‍

Vegan Prozac Chocolate cake w/ chocolate icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Plain Jane Vanilla cake w/ vanilla icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Capote Chocolate cake w/ vanilla icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Classic Vanilla cake w/ chocolate icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Almond Brothers Almond cake w/ almond icing topped w/ toasted almonds Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Grasshopper Chocolate cake w/ delicious peppermint icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Cookies N’ Cream Who knew‍ oreos were vegan? Chocolate cake w/ delicious oreo icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Vegan Chocolate Chimp Chocolate cake w/ banana icing Options: Cakes are two 8 inch layers & cost (36.00) , Cupcakes (24 per dozen.)

Pies

25.00 Vegan Roasty Toasty Apple Roasted apples & toasted pecans fill this delicious flaky pie crust

25.00 Vegan Super Punk Our punkin’ pie gets even punkier when transformed into a vegan-friendly pumpkin pie complete w/ cinnamon goodness

27.00 Vegan Johnny Appleseed Whoa nelly! Apples & brown sugar come together w/ a double-crust for apple pie nirvana

Misc‍

7.80 per dozen Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

Shop

20-50 Cake Plates We get our cake plates from a variety of places. I’m an avid garage saler, so many of these are my finds. Some are vintage, some are reproduction, all are totally adorable. Prices range from

Handmade Unique Aprons Our aprons are made by local crafters & each one is unique, so our selection changes all the time. We also occasionally stock genuine vintage aprons. Stop in & see what we have in stock aprons by love for sale exclusively at muddy’s catie kindelan, & carolyn dodson king. Options: Adult full coverage (35 each) , Adult half style (30 each) , Child size (25 each)

4.50 each Greeting Cards We sell greeting cards w/ artwork by local artists, graphic designers, & small letter press companies. We go out of our way to feature both locals & cards that you can’t find all the over the place. Most are birthday cards because when people pick up their cakes, many are for birthdays but we do have some congrats, miss you, love you, & snark cards too. If you are a local artist, designer, or printer & would like some cards featured here, let us know! We currently have cards by yee haw industries, sycamore street press, paper pastries, dutch door press, tweecards, darling clementine, & morris & essex.

Birthday Candles We sell cake candles in a variety of colors & styles to help make your party special. Options: Single color tapers, 12 per pack (3.00) , Multi color tapers, 24 per pack (6.00) , Twisty multi color tapers, 12 per pack (6.00) , Individual tapers (1 each) , Numbers (2 each)

12.00 Delta Grits Delta grind is a local business just outside of oxford, ms. we’re proud to be a purveyor of their delicious stone-ground grits. 2 lb bags

Raw Honey Ever heard of peace bee farm? Well, they’re kind of a big deal. Pbf is quite nearby, just across the river in arkansas. Their honey is absolutely delicious! Eating local honey has its benefits as well; eating honey made w/ pollen from local plants is said to improve one’s immunity to allergies. And how Options: 16 ounces of raw honey (5.00) , 12 ounce honey bear (3.50)

6.50 each Miss Mildred's Wicked Vanilla Currently Sold Out! Mildred is‍ the alias of memphis native courtney shove. Mildred comes to muddy’s from time to time to make her special homemade vanilla extract. The vanilla is bottled in darling little amber apothecary bottles & makes a delightful hostess gift, birthday prezzie, or special little happy for any occasion.

15 each Artgoodies Tea Towels These fantastic tea towels are hand printed by textile craftswoman lisa price. We carry the following designs: single cupcake, quad-cupcake, swirl, cherry pie, & diamond solitaire.

22 each No Substitutions Tee Shirt Yay printed on American apparel tri blend track shirts in evergreen, these super soft tees are awesome. Thanks to customer elise addington for requesting the tri blend shirts you’re right, elise, it’s soft enough to sleep in

3 each Cup a Cake These are so adorable customer connie brought one back from out of town & so we started carrying them. These puppies fit one cupcake each & they’re perfect for lunchboxes, sneaking into the movies, etc.

30 each Cupcake Stand / Hors D’Oeuvres Tier I searched high & low for the perfect cupcake stand for y’all & this is totally it it has three flat tiers (rather than individual cupcake holders) so that you can put a range of cupcakes rather than a set number; it fits up to 40 muddy’s cupcakes comfortably. It can also be dismantled easily for flat storage! This is a huge perk because if you’re like me, you don’t particularly want to dedicate an entire cabinet to storing a party-piece you’ll only use a few times a year. We try to keep some stocked already put together & some still in boxes, in case you are planning to ship it.